Yo Pauly’s New York Pizza: Authentic NY-style Pizza Experience in Scottsdale

Picked up a pizza with all pepperoni and half mushroom on my way home and couldn’t resist grabbing a couple slices right away. It totally hit the spot, no complaints at all. If you’re into garlic, definitely add it, it really pulls all the flavors together.

Great NY pizza. As a former Nyer I know what makes it so. However, wish the bottom crust was cooked a little more to make it crack when you fold it in half. All in all good sauce taste, right amount of oil & cheese a little more pep & sausage would be nice. But a winner go try a Ziggy's pie. We got 18 inch for 4 of us 2 slices each wish I had gotten the 24 inch for leftovers. Friendly service, order a pie at the counter then sit down for a treat.

We were looking on google to find a good Pizza/calzone place. It’s a cute pizza shop that has outdoor seating. We are a bit harder on our review in this category because my boyfriend is from Naples Italy and we’ve had some of the best pizza/calzones there. We got the Little Italy and Tri State Calzone. The Tri State was the better of the 2 but both were good. I’d recommend Yo Paulys to friends and family.

Absolutely amazing experience! From the moment my family and I walked in, we were greeted with such a genuinely warm and loving welcome. The customer service was truly above and beyond anything we’ve experienced elsewhere. We’re visiting from California, and finding a new place that completely knocks it out of the park on the very first visit is rare—especially for our big family of seven. My family loved the food (cheese pizza, stromboli, calzone, garlic knots and caesar salad were all a hit), and the atmosphere was beautifully down-to-earth, inviting, and comfortable. We also really appreciated how open and spacious it was, with seating that easily accommodated our large family—something that’s hard to come by. The owners should be incredibly proud of what they’ve created here. The next time we visit, this will be the only pizza place we’ll be coming to. Highly recommend!

Im from NYC and I had to see what the NY STYLE PIZZA is like. I grabbed a cheese and a corner Sicilian slice. The cheese slice was actually really good. Good char, good crisp and cheese was not oily at all. By far the closest to NY Style pizza I've had in Arizona

This was our first time and we will definitely be back! The food was amazing! Like really good! The pizza came out and the cheese was molten and the crust was crispy just like a good pizza should be! The staff were all really friendly. I had interactions with several of them and all were really nice. 10/10 recommend!

Yo Pauly’s New York Pizza Co is my go-to when I want dependable pizza delivery that actually tastes fresh when it arrives. The crust has that perfect New York-style fold, the sauce is flavorful without being overpowering, and the toppings are generous and well balanced. Delivery is usually on time, and the pizza arrives hot and ready to enjoy. Everything feels made with care rather than rushed. It’s a solid local choice when you’re craving classic pizza delivered straight to your door.

The pizza is legit. The cheese, the sauce, it all tastes correct. Good crunch to the crust. Foldable, but ngl I did expect it to be a tad bit bigger. All in all though a good slice, I did enjoy it. The interior of the restaurant is a little campy, but they’re trying to recreate the old school pizzeria vibe, it’s fine. Parking can be tough, the lot is small and there’s a few other businesses in the vicinity. If you’re in the area they’re worth a visit for sure.